|
About > The Slush Pile
While working as an editorial intern in children's book publishing, one of my main duties was to go through "slush" -- unsolicited manuscripts. When I arrived in September, there was a floor-to-ceiling bookshelf crammed full of mail dating back eight months. By the time I left in November, 20 days of work later, there was only a shelf and a half left, less than crammed, dating back "only" three months. I went through armfuls of mail a day. My supervisors repeatedly apologized that I had to do such grunt work, but it never failed to entertain me. Every elementary school teacher and every grandmother thinks she can write a picture book. Here are some of my favorite excerpts. All quotes are direct and exact, although I have removed some identifying information (I was actually emailed by author -- er, medium? -- of the first book listed here, back when I had the book title included).
.
I. Cover and Query Letters .
1)
I have channeled a book: [Book Title Here]. In ancient times, a common girl, referred to a girl who took part in spiritual ceremonies. This book has its origins from the Druids of King Arther's time. It is a book of Druid Magic. It shows you how to call your Goddess, Power of you Area, and Archangels, plus many more.
. 2)
Ahh, she wants us to Publish her stories? Cause you know, I get confused.
. 3)
.
4)
.
5)
Kate K, a 6th grader from Texas, sent us her first novel along with a photocopy of her last report card! (She had five absences all year and her final grades range from 96 (math) to 99 (health). There's a stamp on it that says "great job / your principal!").
.
6)
.
7)
.
8)
My favorite letterhead so far comes from an illustrator. There is a row of different colored dots across the top and below it, "polka dots to make you happy." Which did indeed make me smile. And then at the bottom, under another row of brightly colored dots, "buying art brings good luck." Hehe. Unfortunately, the story is not so good: A rhyming picture book whose chorus is "Hey there little insect, please calm down / So we can have fun and fool around!"
I have been informed by several people that these are lyrics to a song by Jonathan Richman. Alas, I don't remember whether he submitted this manuscript in hopes of publishing a picture book, or whether someone else was plagiarizing him.
. .
II. Winning Excerpts
.
1)
. 2)
Tasty, eh? And yes, this is a boy talking, not a dog.
. 3)
Kebrina K, "the original psychic to the stars," has written "a coming of age story of sixteen year old Samantha Grayson, a teenage budding psychic."
Of course, the writing is as stellar as the celebrities Kebrina makes predictions for ... Samantha is writing in her diary about her upcoming trip to France:
. 4)
Cover letter: Wow. That is really just too much. The writing of the manuscript is good too...
. 5)
This historical novel opens with a hunter who shoots, "narrowly missing a peasant"...
. 6)
Jerry Jack gets all the toys he wanted for Christmas and invites his friends to come play, and they all say no, they can't come, they have to spend time with their families because their dad got laid off from work or their mom is in the hospital or something. So finally Jerry Jack gets the idea to give away some of his new toys to his friends, since they didn't get anything and he feels bad and a little spoiled. Wow, it feels good to give, he thinks. Near the end of this picture book manuscript a Marine comes to his house collecting for toys for tots, and Jerry Jack donates the last of his Christmas presents. Here comes the best part: The Marine says, "you've made quite a sacrifice for a little boy," and Jerry Jack says, "Sergeant, that's nothing compared to the sacrifices Jesus made for you and me."
. 7)
. .
III. The All-Time Best Picture Book Idea
Yessir, whenever his mother got the vacuum cleaner out he would hug and kiss it, and she had to pry him away every time. And she bought him toys and pets to try to displace his affection, but he would still run straight for the vacuum cleaner every time she pulled it out from the closet, kissing it madly.
I am NOT making this up.
. .
IV. The All-Time Weirdest Letter I Received
An old friend of mine one Thomas B, XXX WF Drive, BR, LA XXXXX sent me the book 'Treasure Island' by Robert Louise (sic) Stephenson and published by you. Of the 286 numbered pages all are printed in English with the exception of pages 49 to 64 and 241 to 256 inclusive, which are printed in Spanish.
I would be pleased if you could write to me and tell me what I should do as I find this unacceptable.
Yours faithfully . .
V. Final Thoughts:
. 1)
Remind me never to move to western Nebraska, where, Cynthia C. tells me, "the only radio stations are country western and KSOU (playing the best in pow-wow music -- that is their slogan for real)."
. 2)
Why is it that people write stories about their dogs and then send ugly photographs of them along with the manuscript? I'm a dog person, mind you, but these photographs aren't even flattering. I'm supposed to think the dog is cute and therefore want to publish a story about it? And the stories, sadly, they're much much worse.
. 3)
If I see another letter that says "the purpose of this book is to celebrate difference and what makes us each unique" it goes straight to the trash.
. 4)
Finally, I would like to tell the world of slush-senders (though these are my preferences and I can't speak for other editors):
.
Thanks for reading. You can also find out what I thought about some picture books that have already been published, or check out what I've been reading lately.
|
Last updated October 21, 2005